Showing posts with label rhetoric and composition. Show all posts
Showing posts with label rhetoric and composition. Show all posts

Friday, February 23, 2024

A Problematic Arm on the Deep Web's Evil Kraken of Lawlessness

Here's an unexpected opening to a Writing Program Administrator's blog post:

Authoritarians stand to gain the most when educators place political dissidents in the same category as criminals who victimize the innocent and exploit the weak. 

So, it's probably not okay that a popular infographic often used to teach about digital literacy places political dissidents in the same category as illegal porn, drugs, and stolen credit cards. 

I mean, maybe some people might think it acceptable, but I am not one of those people.  

Many of my heroes have been labeled as political dissidents at one time or another: Angela Davis, Václav Havel, Mahatma Gandhi, Malala Yousafzai, Carlos Fonseca, Thomas Sankara, Emma Goldman, Martin Luther King Jr., Nelson Mandela, Liu Xiaobo, Harriet Tubman, and the list goes on. 

While none of these people were perfect, they all worked and sacrificed to restrain the unjust use of power in the hands of authorities (authorities who deemed themselves completely legitimate). It's a sacrifice I admire above most.

Imagine my surprise then when the infographic popped on-screen during a classroom discussion I was leading on how writing instructors should invite input from other experts when teaching topics such as information literacy.

The students had a good laugh when I stopped dead in my tracks while reading aloud the list of things found in this dangerous part of the deep web. I turned to them and asked, "Is illegal porn really in the same boat as political dissidents?" 

They didn't think so.

The infographic was part of a library tutorial on information literacy that we share with first-year students. When asked about it, our librarians quickly acknowledged that the equivalence was problematic. They agreed to pull the graphic. 

A happy outcome locally, but I was curious about how widespread use of the image was.   

The infographic was originally published in 2014 by CNN Money. It has since found its way onto several different places online. For example, a 2023 post in Writing Commons, instructions for developing college-level library database tutorials, and a university journal that publishes the exceptional work of graduate students. So, it should not be a shock that the image pops up on other university library tutorials or that it became part of our university's tutorial to teach students about researching online.

The subject isn't an easy one to teach, and the infographic does look great. Nearly all of the information on it is informative and accurate. I can understand why people building lessons around this subject would miss the bit about political dissidents being an arm of the evil Kraken of lawlessness. 

But... it is also typically used in a class that focuses on critical reading. So, there is that.

And yeah, there is also probably something to be written about the infographic's origin being a news outlet operated by an international megacorporation that is deeply invested in the current status quo, but I think it better to leave things here: 

Education tools are not perfect. This doesn't make them useless or malevolent, but it does mean that educators and students need to stay sharp and critical when teaching and learning.  

Wednesday, March 22, 2023

Listening to the Divide

Led a difficult Writing Program meeting last week.

I enjoyed it because the faculty were helpful and engaged, but it was a tough one. 

We discussed our instructor evaluation procedures and how they impact the scheduling process. 

It's just a difficult topic.

There was a division that I noted, and I need to sort out what that division means for a Writing Program Coordinator. 

On one side of the division, we have faculty who see the challenge of teaching in a comprehensive regional university that has recently ended remediation, and they've responded in this way: My task as a professional is to find teaching and assessment practices that support this population of students and their progress toward our learning outcomes.

On the other side of the division, we have faculty who know they are teaching courses with class caps that are too high and students who lack the support they need to meet the demands our learning outcomes present. These faculty members see the situation this way: Too many of these students do not have the resources they need to pass my course, and I am the one who gets unjustly blamed for that. 

I'm gonna admit, as an instructor, I know which side of the divide I stand on. But that doesn't mean shit.

My job is to make sure these sides don't see each other as adversaries. My job is to hear these two sides and determine what kind of support they need. And then to figure out how to provide that support.

I've written about the need to strengthen our school's support system for student writers. The system is there, but it needs help because our required courses are not enough for many of our students. They need to have resources - but more importantly - to use resources outside the classroom to grow as writers. 

I engaged in an interesting (and related) conversation with an instructor shortly after the meeting. This person was concerned (rightfully) about the outsized impact student feedback has on instructor evaluations. One of the problems mentioned was that students create outside chat groups that do not include the instructor via Discord or Slack. A negative leader in such spaces can sour a class in very little time, and there's not much an instructor can do once that occurs. 

And I recognize that issue. We began discussing how to implement solutions.

But then something was said that didn't feel right. The instructor expressed frustration because, they claimed, students using these apps rely on each other for help on assignments rather than asking the instructor.    

See, that shouldn't frustrate anyone. I read that as a huge positive, not just for the students, but also for the instructor. Part of our goal in a Writing Program is to prepare students to write without the support of a composition instructor. We know they will face new writing challenges in their major and in their post-collegiate endeavors. Students who actively seek out support from peers beyond the boundaries of the classroom are demonstrating a kind of resourcefulness that they will need when instructors are no longer there to support them. The fact that they are already doing this is kind of awesome. We should wear that like a badge. 

I don't want composition instructors to believe that they are entirely responsible for the writing development of their students. Students must be able to work with the instructor and all of the other resources present in the community to grow as writers.  

But taking that position isn't easy if students and/or faculty don't believe the resources are available or sufficient. 

So, that divide is informative, no matter what side of it I'm on. I recognize that building up student support, offering more paid professional development, and establishing a lecturer mentoring program are all parts of the mix, but this experience helped me see one other thing I should set my sights on.

I got the idea on Saturday when I went to Avid Reader Books in Sacramento and I got to see Jodi Angel do a reading from her new book, Biggest Little Girl. Jodi is a friend from my days in the UCD fiction writing program, and her reading was stunningly powerful. 

The author who read before Jodi is Josh Fernandez, who read from an upcoming memoir, The Hands that Crafted the Bomb (coming out this winter). Josh is also a composition instructor at Folsom Lake College, and the reading provided an insightful, powerful, humorous, and devastating look at what it means to teach composition today. 

As I listened, I realized I need to listen more. I need to provide a space for voices like Josh's and other composition instructors. 

Our students, our faculty, our administrators, and our community need to know what it means to teach writing in these times. 

So, I have a project. I gotta find some money for prizes and organize a Creative Non-Fiction on Composition Competition (oh, and I gotta ask Josh if he'd be a judge). I think it could be fun. It'll be work - but work well worth it. 

Wednesday, February 22, 2023

Reflecting on #4C23 Remediation and the Student-Ready University

On Sunday, I returned home from Chicago where I was attending the Conference on College Composition and Communication (CCCC [but we say "See's"]). 

It was a trip back in time on a few levels, and more than once, it had me thinking about an exchange from way back in 2003 about working with students who still have a long way to go in their development as writers.

I shouldn't be surprised that the conference sent me into my past. The last time I attended an in-person conference was 2019. And on another detour down memory lane, the conference was a block away from Columbia College Chicago, where I spent my first year of college as a theater and fiction writing student. Then after the conference, I hopped on a train to visit family in Milwaukee, the place I grew up. 

So, my head was in a space where I was often looking backward to look forward. All of which very likely contributed to this specific 20-year-old memory being brought to mind a few times. 

Jack Hicks was trying to get us creative writing MA students to understand a certain frame of mind that is essential for anyone planning to teach writing. He asked what an instructor should do with students who 'can't write worth a damn' (paraphrasing here, but trying to get Jack's tone right). We students all tried to give thoughtful answers, but after some struggle, Jack interrupted us and said, "There's nothing you can do. Your job is to take them where they are." 

It was one of those moments when the correctness of the answer was only obvious after it had been spoken, but then it was so obvious that it was greeted with an embarrassed silence. 

That lesson has shaped the way I think about placement and pedagogy to this day. Our job in FYC is to open the door of higher education for the students the institution has admitted. And if I'm abiding by my values, I am pushing the institution to open that door as wide as possible. And yeah, that means the skill level of students entering is not where it was 20 or 40 years ago - or even 5 years ago. I don't see that as a failure. 

But I do acknowledge it as a challenge. 

Because the goals we pursue in FYC remain. I think of it this way: We work to foster the writing development of students so they can, in time, compose texts that will give them a voice in the academic, scholarly, professional, social, and civic communities they join.   

Or, as we put it in the Sac State Writing Program mission: In the Sacramento State University Writing Program, we engage students from diverse cultural and linguistic backgrounds to develop reflective, analytical, and collaborative literacy practices, empowering them to communicate effectively.

It's a bold set of goals that requires a network of support capable of reaching across multiple classrooms and learning resources. 

At and since CCCC, I've heard from a number of people describing how those goals might be too bold for the network of support we have to work with in FYC. 

The most public expression of that concern came during the Opening General Session at CCCC. Joanne Baird Giordano was delivering the greeting from the Two-Year College English Association (TYCA). It was a brilliant address that called on the conference to recognize the impact and importance of the labor and expertise present in two-year schools and open-admission four-year institutions. It's a call I will work to heed. There was, however, one part of the call that complicates my understanding of "Take them where they are." 

Giordano called on us all to "recognize that some writing and developmental education reforms imposed on community colleges by legislators and state systems are austerity measures masquerading as equity." 

This was a clear reference to, among other things, the end of remediation in the Cal State system and the California Community College system. And I'm not sure how I feel about Giordano's critique. 

On one hand, I agree that many students need additional support for their writing development when they start college. And often that support should take the shape of additional instruction. We move in the wrong direction if (and when) instructional resources are lost or defunded in the name of reforms to higher education. I agree with that and I think that's what Joanne Baird Giordano was getting at.

The end of remediation, however, doesn't have to result in the loss or defunding of instructional resources. It should mean the reshaping and reconfiguration of such resources. 

I get nervous when I hear people argue that ending remediation is a failure to support our students. The argument is a messy one.

With the right amount of nuance, I do support the argument. For example, I'm all in on this version: Ending remediation without providing new forms of support to replace what's being removed is a cynical way administrators tell composition faculty to 'Do more with less' while quietly accepting lower standards for our students.

When policy is getting made, however, arguments like this one are rarely allowed that level of nuance. They typically become a version of this: Ending remediation is administrators telling composition faculty to 'Do more with less' while quietly accepting lower standards for our students.

That's the argument used to support mandated remedial courses for students who perform poorly on a test (or a different set of measures) as determined by administrators like me.

And I don't agree with that argument. I support the end of mandated remediation as it has been implemented for decades: As a gate-keeping tool that excluded people from a college education based on a set of criteria developed by patriarchal institutions that center a limited kind of whiteness, a hate-based take on sexuality, and a profoundly exclusive understanding of socioeconomic status.  

That deeply problematic use of mandated remediation needs to be rejected along with the chorus of arguments about good intentions that support it: "We're just thinking of the future challenges these students will face," "Some kids just aren't made for college," "Students can't be held responsible for past teachers' failures," "Admitting students who aren't ready is cruel because they will just fail later after being told they could succeed."

The research and practices compositionists engage in should not treat certain students as people who require a remedy. A remedy is something provided to set right an undesirable situation. The students we work with in FYC are not in an undesirable situation. They are first-year students at a university that will serve as the setting for a years-long endeavor to grow and learn. That shit is dope and deserves to be celebrated.  

The criteria used to argue for mandating remedial courses must be removed from the deeply problematic history they inhabit. 

But we also need to acknowledge the circumstances that generated those criteria: A diverse population of learners needs a diverse set of resources to support their development as writers. And yeah, those resources require investment in our institutions. We need space, experts, and buy-in from everyone who serves our students. 

The required courses are not enough for some of our students. It is therefore our obligation to provide additional resources that students can utilize to support their own writing development. And we are also obligated to make sure students have access to and understanding of those resources. 
  • Writing Centers with specialists
  • Credit-bearing and non-credit-bearing access to peer tutors
  • Accessible and inclusive writing prompts and syllabi
  • Representation of diverse student identities reflected in the faculty
  • Representation of diverse student identities reflected in the readings
  • Stretch sections of composition
  • Multilingual sections of composition
  • Low-stakes assessment moments that serve as advising tools
  • Antiracist and inclusive assessment practices
  • And this list is not exhaustive!
And then there's an additional challenge once these resources get put in place. Faculty, staff, administrators, advisors, and peers need to understand this network of support so they can navigate it or guide others. 

It's a lot, but it is also the work required to enact the values of our discipline. 

Monday, January 16, 2023

The False Narrative of Good and Evil with ChatGPT

The New York Times published another article on ChatGPT today. This one is a well-research piece by Kalley Huang who interviewed professors, students, and administrators to learn about higher education's response to ChatGPT. 

Huang's reporting confirms a lot of what I've been hearing in the discussions I'm being pulled into as a Writing Program Administrator. 

But there is an issue with how the larger story is developing, and Huang's piece demonstrates that issue.

I posted the following comment: 

Higher education is being framed as a form of policing in this article, and that is deeply frustrating. 

The question not asked in this reporting is important for context. How has the lumbering behemoth of higher education marshaled a response to this disruptive Silicon Valley technology within two months of ChatGPT's launch? 

The answer is simple. The responses to this disruption are all well-established practices developed by scholars of Composition & Rhetoric (a discipline that, among other things, studies the development of writing ability in college settings).

Here are the "innovations" described in this article: Mr. Aumann will support his student's writing by including low-stakes in-class writing exercises that build towards the more significant assignment. Professors are going to develop more collaborative writing assignments. Assignments include reflection and revision memos. "Gone are prompts like 'write five pages about this or that.'” Professors will look beyond the canon for assignment prompts. Writing instructors will teach students about the benefits and pitfalls of new writing technologies. Institutions are going to revisit their academic integrity policies. 

That list describes the basics required to teach writing. It is not a response to attempts to cheat. We Compositionists are not plagiarism police. Our job is to teach students why writing their own paper is more valuable than submitting an "A paper."

I get pointed questions about student cheating all the time, especially when I work with people to make changes in higher education writing settings. People love to imagine ways students will cheat. 

And yeah, I can name a number of times I have identified papers or passages that were lifted from other sources. I'm not here to say it's a non-issue.

But I am here to say that the public likes to think of things using established narratives, and the following narratives are very popular:

  • Cheating students outwit professors
  • Professors catch cheating students
From School Library
These are stories we like to tell. And because these stories do happen from time to time, they become the stories we tell most often. News articles, department meetings, conference presentations, blog posts, op-eds in the Chronicle of Higher Education (so often), Tiktoks, Tweet threads, family gatherings, professional small talk sessions, everywhere we look!

And if you have a good plagiarism story, people lean in to listen. You get rewarded with engagement. 
The most common one I used to hear was about students who figured out ways to outwit Turnitin.com. People love those tales.

And I am very much aware of this happening again with ChatGPT. 

I would like to remind everyone of this 9-year-old gem from Neil deGrasse Tyson:

We must re-examine our practices if our students don't understand why we are teaching the very challenging processes of writing to learn and writing to contribute to a community.

If we don't teach students the value of doing their own writing, our course is nothing more than a hoop to jump through... Or worse, a gate intended to withhold opportunity from some in favor of others. 

Wednesday, December 28, 2022

A.I. Chatbots and Composition

 

I'm working on a series of responses to the ways new technologies are going to impact the composition classroom. This is the first video, an attempt to put ChatGPT into the context of Rhetoric and Composition's history. 

I'm working on one that addresses the issue of academic integrity.  

False Dichotomies Are Either the Answer or the Apocalypse

Earlier this week, my colleague and friend Sasha Sidorkin published a post on the AI in Society blog , which he maintains as part of his wo...