Showing posts with label technology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label technology. Show all posts

Friday, February 23, 2024

A Problematic Arm on the Deep Web's Evil Kraken of Lawlessness

Here's an unexpected opening to a Writing Program Administrator's blog post:

Authoritarians stand to gain the most when educators place political dissidents in the same category as criminals who victimize the innocent and exploit the weak. 

So, it's probably not okay that a popular infographic often used to teach about digital literacy places political dissidents in the same category as illegal porn, drugs, and stolen credit cards. 

I mean, maybe some people might think it acceptable, but I am not one of those people.  

Many of my heroes have been labeled as political dissidents at one time or another: Angela Davis, Václav Havel, Mahatma Gandhi, Malala Yousafzai, Carlos Fonseca, Thomas Sankara, Emma Goldman, Martin Luther King Jr., Nelson Mandela, Liu Xiaobo, Harriet Tubman, and the list goes on. 

While none of these people were perfect, they all worked and sacrificed to restrain the unjust use of power in the hands of authorities (authorities who deemed themselves completely legitimate). It's a sacrifice I admire above most.

Imagine my surprise then when the infographic popped on-screen during a classroom discussion I was leading on how writing instructors should invite input from other experts when teaching topics such as information literacy.

The students had a good laugh when I stopped dead in my tracks while reading aloud the list of things found in this dangerous part of the deep web. I turned to them and asked, "Is illegal porn really in the same boat as political dissidents?" 

They didn't think so.

The infographic was part of a library tutorial on information literacy that we share with first-year students. When asked about it, our librarians quickly acknowledged that the equivalence was problematic. They agreed to pull the graphic. 

A happy outcome locally, but I was curious about how widespread use of the image was.   

The infographic was originally published in 2014 by CNN Money. It has since found its way onto several different places online. For example, a 2023 post in Writing Commons, instructions for developing college-level library database tutorials, and a university journal that publishes the exceptional work of graduate students. So, it should not be a shock that the image pops up on other university library tutorials or that it became part of our university's tutorial to teach students about researching online.

The subject isn't an easy one to teach, and the infographic does look great. Nearly all of the information on it is informative and accurate. I can understand why people building lessons around this subject would miss the bit about political dissidents being an arm of the evil Kraken of lawlessness. 

But... it is also typically used in a class that focuses on critical reading. So, there is that.

And yeah, there is also probably something to be written about the infographic's origin being a news outlet operated by an international megacorporation that is deeply invested in the current status quo, but I think it better to leave things here: 

Education tools are not perfect. This doesn't make them useless or malevolent, but it does mean that educators and students need to stay sharp and critical when teaching and learning.  

Monday, January 16, 2023

The False Narrative of Good and Evil with ChatGPT

The New York Times published another article on ChatGPT today. This one is a well-research piece by Kalley Huang who interviewed professors, students, and administrators to learn about higher education's response to ChatGPT. 

Huang's reporting confirms a lot of what I've been hearing in the discussions I'm being pulled into as a Writing Program Administrator. 

But there is an issue with how the larger story is developing, and Huang's piece demonstrates that issue.

I posted the following comment: 

Higher education is being framed as a form of policing in this article, and that is deeply frustrating. 

The question not asked in this reporting is important for context. How has the lumbering behemoth of higher education marshaled a response to this disruptive Silicon Valley technology within two months of ChatGPT's launch? 

The answer is simple. The responses to this disruption are all well-established practices developed by scholars of Composition & Rhetoric (a discipline that, among other things, studies the development of writing ability in college settings).

Here are the "innovations" described in this article: Mr. Aumann will support his student's writing by including low-stakes in-class writing exercises that build towards the more significant assignment. Professors are going to develop more collaborative writing assignments. Assignments include reflection and revision memos. "Gone are prompts like 'write five pages about this or that.'” Professors will look beyond the canon for assignment prompts. Writing instructors will teach students about the benefits and pitfalls of new writing technologies. Institutions are going to revisit their academic integrity policies. 

That list describes the basics required to teach writing. It is not a response to attempts to cheat. We Compositionists are not plagiarism police. Our job is to teach students why writing their own paper is more valuable than submitting an "A paper."

I get pointed questions about student cheating all the time, especially when I work with people to make changes in higher education writing settings. People love to imagine ways students will cheat. 

And yeah, I can name a number of times I have identified papers or passages that were lifted from other sources. I'm not here to say it's a non-issue.

But I am here to say that the public likes to think of things using established narratives, and the following narratives are very popular:

  • Cheating students outwit professors
  • Professors catch cheating students
From School Library
These are stories we like to tell. And because these stories do happen from time to time, they become the stories we tell most often. News articles, department meetings, conference presentations, blog posts, op-eds in the Chronicle of Higher Education (so often), Tiktoks, Tweet threads, family gatherings, professional small talk sessions, everywhere we look!

And if you have a good plagiarism story, people lean in to listen. You get rewarded with engagement. 
The most common one I used to hear was about students who figured out ways to outwit Turnitin.com. People love those tales.

And I am very much aware of this happening again with ChatGPT. 

I would like to remind everyone of this 9-year-old gem from Neil deGrasse Tyson:

We must re-examine our practices if our students don't understand why we are teaching the very challenging processes of writing to learn and writing to contribute to a community.

If we don't teach students the value of doing their own writing, our course is nothing more than a hoop to jump through... Or worse, a gate intended to withhold opportunity from some in favor of others. 

Wednesday, December 28, 2022

A.I. Chatbots and Composition

 

I'm working on a series of responses to the ways new technologies are going to impact the composition classroom. This is the first video, an attempt to put ChatGPT into the context of Rhetoric and Composition's history. 

I'm working on one that addresses the issue of academic integrity.  

False Dichotomies Are Either the Answer or the Apocalypse

Earlier this week, my colleague and friend Sasha Sidorkin published a post on the AI in Society blog , which he maintains as part of his wo...